Now that the election is over, America is gripped by an arguably bigger rivalry: David Cook vs. David Archuleta.
Rocker David might have been crowned the American Idol this year, beating out Lil’ David by more than 12 million votes, but does that also mean he’ll have a bigger career too?
Let’s compare them, shall we?
In this corner, David Archuleta. Self-titled album. Release date: Nov. 11.
-He’s the kind of pop star–sweet, boyish, non-threatening–who elicits a devoted following made up of both tweens and grannies alike. In fact his fans have dubbed themselves “Arch Angels.”
-His self-titled, “Crush,” debuted at #2 on the Billboard Hot 100.
Cons:
-He comes across as young and naive, especially when taking into account his album’s liner notes, which total 3,500 freakin’ words. Will such an earnest guy be able to survive the big, bad music business and…
-His dad/manager, often rumored to be the stage-dad from hell?
And in this corner, David Cook. Self-titled album. Release date: Nov. 18.
Pros:
-Um, he won American Idol, garrnering 56% of the votes. 
-He’s been very high-profile since his win. Not only has he performed on Saturday Night Live, he also won ”Best Reality/Variety Star” award at the 2008 Teen Choice Awards and has an endorsement deal with Skechers.
Cons:
-His first single, “Light On,” only debuted at #17 on the Billboard Hot 100.
-His fanbase doesn’t seem to have a catchy nickname, which probably means they aren’t as rabid as Archuleta’s. [UPDATE: A commenter points out that his fans are called "Word Nerds" because Cook loves crossword puzzles. But still, the victor of an epic battle between Archangels and Word Nerds seems obvious, doesn't it?]
Seems to me the Davids are evenly matched. Predicto Mobile users are split as well – 54% predicted that David Cook will sell more albums than David Archuleta in their first week of sales.
Check out Predicto.com to see how you can get in on the voting action today!
Mr. Predicto

Posted by Predicto 
Posted by Predicto 
Posted by Predicto 






